Skip to content
Premium Track Lab

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: Artemisia Gentileschi’s Dynamic Mary Magdalene.

A woman leans her head backwards. Her eyes are shut, her mouth is closed, yet she is fully conscious. Sporting flushed cheeks and vermilion lips, her flowing golden hair reflects the glow from a single flame, casting a radiant aura in an predominantly gloomy room. Her attire includes a lace-trimmed blouse—falling down one shoulder to expose porcelain skin—to a heavy ochre and amethyst cloth. Seemingly by herself, unaware of any onlooker, existing in a state of sublime autonomy.

An Important Institutional First

This subject is Mary Magdalene depicted in ecstasy, crafted in the early 1620s by the Italian Baroque artist Gentileschi. Freshly purchased by the prestigious institution in Washington, DC, it is set to go on display from late February. It represents the institution’s maiden purchase of a work by the artist, and expert a leading scholar has noted that it shows the saint as “neither repentant nor suffering”. This is an important difference, for centuries, Magdalene’s representation has been crafted not just by biblical text but mythologized and blurred by powerful men.

“The most versatile woman in sacred iconography,” as one academic stated.

Study images of her and you find a reader, orator, disciple, and witness; crying at the base of the crucifix, anointing Christ’s feet, or gazing toward the sky—frequently atoning with shimmering tears and, conveniently, exposing her bosom. At times identified by a jar of ointment or a crimson garment—unlike the Virgin Mary’s blue—she is most popularly known nowadays as a prostitute, even though no biblical passage describing her as such.

Unraveling the Historical Figure

“In reality, we cannot be certain who she was,” said the scholar. “Consequently, numerous strata of meaning have been placed upon her. Her evolution she experiences, not just in art but in story, in worship, theologically, are as much related to societal views and theological shifts as they are to belief.” So what do we know?

Mary Magdalene is mentioned in the New Testament 12 times. Initially, she has evil spirits cast out from her; subsequently, she is seen at the execution and is the primary person to see his rising. She is the one who spreads the “gospel”. Her sensual and sinful legacy can largely be linked to a sermon delivered in the late sixth century by Pope Gregory the Great, who combined her with another Mary and an unnamed sinner who washed Jesus’s feet with her tears.

By collapsing them into one, he effectively “invented” the repentant fallen woman—a myth further expanded by later church fathers and medieval texts. Painters and sculptors took note, and in a largely illiterate but image-savvy world, this proved highly impactful. The “seven demons” became the “cardinal vices”, establishing her dominant narrative as one of sexual fall and subsequent redemption—solidified in artistic renderings that still influence beliefs today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

Consider Donatello’s gaunt, skeletal figure wringing her hands in penitence, to another master’s seventeenth-century portrayal of her devoid of color and near death—alongside Rubens’ semi-nude, rapturous Magdalene held aloft by angels. Mary Magdalene has often been diminished through objectification. One artist’s print presented her coyly, with flowing hair covering her unclothed body, while Titian’s interpretation gazes heavenward, with tearful eyes and carefully placed hands exposing her form.

It seems, suffering and sexualization were the dominant poles in her depiction: she could serve as a warning against transgression, be the poster girl for contrition, while providing artists a excuse to paint the female form veiled as piety. The “fallen woman redeemed” narrative endured for hundreds of years—so deeply that asylums known as “Magdalene laundries” forced women into exploitative labor, a practice that shockingly only closed a mere thirty years ago.

Through a Woman’s Eyes

But what if there was a different facet to her story? Imagine if her journey could be one of enlightenment and transformation, where she was shown as vibrant, delight, and sublimity? In other words, what if we saw her via the lens of a woman?

This is what Artemisia accomplishes. This Magdalene is not posing for the audience; she is not weeping, not repenting, without shame, not objectified, and not dictating a moral lesson. Instead, she has flushed cheeks and is, according to notes, “passionately alive … in the grip of divine joy”. One curator stated that Gentileschi “endows Mary Magdalene with an electrifying vitality”.

“Yes, it’s an rapture painting, but it’s not her moment of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … spoken of sometimes as if it’s the finest sexual encounter … the greatest ecstasy she could ever have. It’s aesthetic, it’s physical, it’s sensual, it’s transcendent. You are lifted beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Often, when female artists portray scriptural or mythological women, they present them not as submissive, sinful, shameful, or subordinate, but as agentic, multifaceted, and with minds of their own: “Females with a capital ‘W’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Therefore, while this recent Gentileschi may ultimately be correcting a representational imbalance at the gallery, its significance extends further. It changes not just how we perceive biblical and archetypal women, but also the female experience in general.

This view is one the Catholic church eventually acknowledged. In the late 1960s, it formally recognized her official role as a faithful follower rather than a sinful repenter. More recently 2016, the pontiff raised her ranking to “apostle to the apostles”, marking 22 July as her feast day. This indicates that, as institutions evolve, viewpoints are transforming. This new purchase—of a woman liberated from a patriarchal gaze, living for her own sake, without anguish and not exploited—is part of a greater shift towards a more balanced representation.

The writer

Jared Smith

Sports analytics expert with over a decade of experience in performance tracking and data science.

Premium Track Lab

Type to search articles.